I got on a call tonight with three parents of teens who wanted to speak about Teen Minyan. JK, BC, and DB. They wanted to talk about "major" issues they saw with Teen Minyan.
It started off way over agressive for no reason, with JK informing me that this wasn't one of those times where you hear something as a suggestion, but rather one of those things that you hear and do. Then he spoke for a long time about how bad the teen minyan is, that its better if we don't have it at the current way, and he is going to gather parents and go to the Vaad with him complaints and suggestions, with me or without me. I stopped him and said that this was a very aggressive opening for a first conversation when we've never spoken about Teen Minyan before. His main complaint - Teen Minyan has talking. (BTW - less than most minyans at the shul, and when it gets to be too much I go tell them to stop). BC and DB raised some other good points, in a much less aggressive way, and then I asked to talk. After he was done, I went point by point, and mentioned whether I agreed with it, or whether I think it isn't realistic/inaccurate. At which point, he told me that he is twice my age, and we aren't on a level playing field, as he is a parent of a teen. The second time he said that he is double my age, I told him "so that means that I have been a teen more recently. My main point was that yes, it would be great to have a silent davening, where people can daven with Kavana, but its not very realistic unless I start being a policeman and not letting people in, which I said I don't want to do. He said, well I am a Shul member paying for your salary, and my kid is my priority, so if thats the decision, you are the employee. And if not, he will suggest to the Vaad to find a replacement. He also said Very weirdly ugly conversation, I kept my cool. He did say that he doesnt blame me, it is the format I was handed. I told him I am there on a high level that ideally we would like TM to be a place of Tefillah, but I am not sure how that vision connects to reality. He said he is going to rally up some other fathers and make a case to the Vaad. If nothing changes he will try to shut down the minyan. One thing also mentioned is how can our minyan finish before 9:30. I explained that our Chazzans are learning, and they don't know how/want to shlep it out, but we do encourage singing. Other suggestions JK came up with was asking Hesder boys/young adults to be there, or to have help monitoring (no young adult that is finally home for shabbat wants to come to that, believe me). And that there should be a hard line, where kids who aren't there to daven will not be welcome at the minyan, even if less kids - it should take a lot longer. Another suggestion was to have a break in the middle for a kiddush and Shiur, which I did not think would go well. Also the rabbi comes anyway (which he said could also be changed, think big).
Look, he is coming from a good place of passion and the desire to make TM a place for inspiration. And I think it would be great if it was, BC gave some good practical suggestions which I will already implement next TM. But its not realistic for 100 boys and girls to be in a room